I do agree with Margaret's decision to break the casserole dish and two green glass cups because she stood up for what means a lot to her by breaking something that meant a lot to Mrs. Cullinan. Margaret's name is her self identity which she cherishes and becomes infuriated with Mrs. Cullinan when she shortens it to Mary to save time. Mrs. Cullinan was too ignorant and racist to understand Margaret's disapproval of her new nickname. After being a servant for a short while, Margaret discovered Mrs. Cullinan's love for the casserole dish and two green cups. By breaking the dishes, she was breaking Mrs. Cullinan's power and superiority. It was a very meaningful message that I believe was necessary. Before the discussion in class, I first responded that I have never been oppressed as a white female. I have never experienced racism and being a female has never restricted me from an opportunity. Although, I have been oppressed by my family regarding my religion. My parents were raised Roman Catholic, with my mom having a stronger faith than my father. Most of my family on my dad's side is deceased, so he lost his enthusiasm for going to church. My mom has a lot of family on her side with both of her parents being alive, several aunts and uncles, and four brothers; all being Catholic. I have been raised Catholic, but have never been forced to go to church. I attended CCD where I received my first communion involuntarily and made the decision not to be confirmed. My grandparents were very disappointed with me, but even more once my parents pulled my little brother out of the program as he did not want to attend without me. Although a teenager, my grandparents have been planning my wedding, my children's names, my children's baptism and everything else I should not be considering at my age. I lost faith once I entered high school which some blame my age for which is understandable. I do not believe in the Bible or most of what the Catholic religion preaches, but I believe in an afterlife and higher being. I believe I only have this belief to stay sane and not as fearful of death. I am one of the first family members on my mom side who does not cherish the Catholic religion which will be a huge dispute as I grow older and consider events such as my wedding.
4 Comments
Sabatino
9/15/2017 07:43:45 am
Thanks for sharing this post. You provide a clear position about Margaret's choice. I wonder if Mrs. Cullinan didn't know how her actions would affect Margaret -- or -- if she didn't care?
Reply
Brianna Costa
9/18/2017 04:56:44 pm
I completely agree with you about supporting her decision! standing up for what you believe in is very important and Margaret does this and it is very motivational.
Reply
Kira
9/18/2017 06:28:23 pm
Maybe since you don't experience oppression yourself, you can stand up for those who do experience it. In matters like those, every single voice counts and you would not hurt anyone by speaking out about it.
Reply
Dominique Candidi
9/21/2017 10:27:25 am
I agree, Mrs. Cullinan took away something that was personal t Margaret making her name worthless. By Margaret breaking the casserole dish and the green coffee glasses she took away Mrs. Cullinan's personal items away that was given to her by her mother.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Caroline
|